​Whether you are in the mood for a piece of pie or planning an event and need several pies, A Slice of Pie can accommodate your needs. Pies are sold in whole and half sizes. Or for a variety, try a "half-n-half" or sampler platter. Slices are sold whole (1/5 pie of a 10" pie) or half (1/8 pie of a 10" pie).

Fruit & Berry Pies

Whole pie: $27.95
​Half pie: $17.50
Whole Slice: $6.45
Half slice: $5.45

• American Apple (double crust and is served with cinnamon sauce)
• Dutch Apple (crumble top)
• Blackberry Crumb
• Cherry Double Crust
• Cherry Raspberry
• Peach (served with cinnamon sauce)
• Strawberry Rhubarb
• Cherry Crumb
• Bumbleberry (4 berry pie; blackberry, raspberry, strawberry and blueberry) price for half: $19; price for whole: $29.95.

American Apple (double crust, served with cinnamon sauce)

Cream Pies

Whole pie: $29.95
Half pie: $19.00
Whole slice : $6.45
Half slice: $5.45

• Boston
• Chocolate (with whipped cream)
• Coconut (with meringue or whipped cream)
• Tahitian (with whipped cream)
• Lemon Meringue

Chocolate Cream Pie

Specialty Pies

All of our specialty pies are served cold or frozen

Whole pie: $27.95
Half pie: $17.50
Whole slice : $6.45
Half slice : $5.45

• Country Custard
• French Silk
• Peanut Butter Lust
• Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl
• Key Lime

Peanut Butter Lust

Pecan, Tollhouse, and Brownie

Whole pie: $29.95
Half pie: $19.00
Whole slice : $6.45
Half slice : $5.45

• Pecan
• Tollhouse
• Fudge Brownie, with ice cream (Plain, Pecan, Andes Mint, Snickers, or Reese's)

Toll House Pie

Frozen Pies

Whole pie: $27.95
Half pie: $17.50
Whole slice : $6.45
Half slice : $5.45

• Key Lime
• Mudslide
• Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl

Pie of the Month

January: Banana Trail Mix
February: Baltimore Bomb Pie & White
​ Chocolate Cappuccino Cheesecake
March: Bailey's Irish Cream Cheesecake
April: Buttermilk
May: Fresh Strawberry
June: Moe's Millionaire
July: Mud Slide
August: Chocolate Chip Mint
September: Chess
October: Pumpkin
November: Dixie (pecan mix, walnuts and chocolate chips)
December: Cranberry Streusel Cheesecake

September Pie of the Month: Chess